City Methodist Church: Unveiling the Captivating History and GothicArchitecture of Gary, Indiana’s Iconic Landmark

Welcome to the enchanting world of City Methodist Church in Gary, Indiana. Nestled at the
intersection of 6th Avenue and Washington Street, this historic church is a captivating example
of Gothic architecture. While it no longer serves as an active place of worship, City Methodist
Church continues to captivate visitors, offering a glimpse into the city’s vibrant history. 
Discover the fascinating tale of its early beginnings, the challenges it faced, and the ongoing
efforts to preserve and revitalize this iconic landmark. 
Join us on a journey through time as we explore the intricate details and the significance of City
Methodist Church.

Where Is City Methodist Church Located?

City Methodist Church

City Methodist Church is located in Gary, Indiana, United States. It is situated at the intersection
of 6th Avenue and Washington Street in downtown Gary. 
This historic church building is an iconic landmark of the city and is known for its impressive
Gothic architecture. Although it is no longer an active place of worship, City Methodist Church
remains a significant cultural and historical site, attracting visitors interested in exploring the
city’s rich past.

History of City Methodist Church

Early Beginnings and Construction

In 1906, the year Gary, Indiana, was founded, a Methodist church was built as well there. Pastor
William Grant Seaman, MD, joined the church in 1916. Seaman wanted to build a larger church
to accommodate Gary’s expanding population, so he approached US Steel, the city’s largest
company, for financial backing. The location for the church was donated by the firm, and they
also paid for roughly half of the building costs. 
In 1925, Chicago architects Lowe and Bollenbacher broke ground on what would take 21
months and an enormous $800,000 to finish. On October 3, 1926, the first worship service at
the new church was held. The city’s namesake, Elbert Gary, gave the church’s organ to the

Expansion and Congregational Growth

The stunning nine-story City Methodist Church complex featured a striking sanctuary at the
center, a 1,000-seat theater next door named Seaman Hall, business facilities, a gym, a Sunday
School, and a dining hall. 
Although they were never carried out, plans for additional amenities like a rooftop garden and
a bowling lane were made. The church had a staff of six and a membership of 1,700 by 1927.

Challenges and Transitions

Dr. William Seaman had some congregational dissatisfaction in 1929, in part as a result of his
efforts to promote cultural variety, which included ecumenical pageants. He was, therefore,
forcefully moved to Ohio. 
Ironically, his replacement was even less well-liked by churchgoers. In accordance with his
desires, Dr. Seaman’s ashes were interred in City Methodist Church after his death in 1944.

Adaptation and Decline

The church leased a part of Seaman Hall to Gary College during the Great Depression, which
helped provide additional funds that were desperately needed. Parts of Seaman Hall were
inhabited in the years following World War II by Indiana University Centre and then Indiana
University Northwest. The church reached its height of popularity in the 1950s when there
were more than 3,000 members. 
However, the church also experienced a decrease in fortunes along with the steel industry and
the city of Gary. Both the town’s populace and the church’s membership had considerably
decreased by the middle of the 1970s. Despite efforts to lease space to the nearby university,
the costs of upkeep for the opulent church become intolerable. City Methodist Church
permanently shut its doors in 1975.

Abandonment and Cultural Significance

City Methodist Church

Following its closure, the church and its surroundings suffered from vandalism and fell into
decay. The abandoned City Methodist Church is now a threatening urban ruin, its once-impressive Gothic design having been weakened by neglect. 
Filmmakers have taken notice of the bleak mood, using the cathedral as a backdrop in films like
Transformers 3 and A Nightmare on Elm Street. Even in its deteriorated and precarious state,
urban explorers frequently visit the location.

Redevelopment Efforts

A grant for converting City Methodist Church into a “ruins garden” with an amphitheater for
weddings and events were given to the Gary Redevelopment Commission in June 2017. With the

help of the award, which was given by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation as part of the
2017 Knight Cities Challenge, the commission was able to start stabilization efforts and carry
out engineering tests to determine the building’s structural soundness. 
However, before any redevelopment can take place, the city needs to address issues such as
flooding and asbestos contamination.

Continued Challenges

Even though City Methodist Church has been preserved and stabilized, there are still many
obstacles to overcome. 2019 saw the site’s asbestos removal, which was made possible by the
Northwest Indiana Regional Development Authority. 
However, in 2022, the city applied for a Brown Fields Cleanup grant from the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency to further address the building’s environmental concerns. 
Unfortunately, the grant was not awarded to the city when the winners were announced in
May 2023. The search for finance and a long-term plan for this historic site is still ongoing,

Why City Methodist Church Is Abandoned?

Due to the following factors and ongoing challenges, City Methodist Church has been
 The declining fortunes of the church were mostly due to the fall of the steel industry,
the city of Gary, and a decline in population. 
 The cost of maintaining the grand church grew unsustainable despite efforts to lease
out space and generate cash. 
 The abandoned church’s state of abandonment deteriorated over time as a result of
neglect, vandalism, and degradation. 
Even though there have been efforts to redevelop, such as securing funding for engineering
studies and stabilization, problems like floods and asbestos pollution still need to be resolved
before any meaningful redevelopment can take place. An ongoing project is looking for funds
and a long-term strategy to revitalize this historic site.

How To Get To The City Methodist Church?

City Methodist Church

You can use the following directions to get to the City Methodist Church:
Location: The City Methodist Church is located in the heart of Gary, Indiana, near the
junction of 6th Avenue and Washington Street.

By Car: To find the church’s location if you’re driving, utilize a GPS navigation system or
a mapping app. Parking may be accessible nearby, but it’s important to verify any rules
or restrictions.
Public Transportation: You can look up the local bus lines that go through downtown
Gary if you choose to take the public transportation option. The City Methodist Church
is conveniently accessible by foot from the closest bus stops.
Taxi or Ride-Sharing: You can also get to the church by taking a taxi or using a ride-
sharing services like Uber or Lyft. The City Methodist Church’s address can be entered
into your ride-hailing app, and the driver will then transport you there.
Walking: The City Methodist Church may be reachable on foot if you are already in the
downtown area. You may easily find the church by going to the crossroads of 6th
Avenue and Washington Street.
It’s important to keep in mind that you might want to check for any special events, limitations,
or closures that could affect access to the site before going to the City Methodist Church.


In conclusion, the City Methodist Church in Gary, Indiana, is a major cultural and historical site
with a colorful past and striking Gothic architecture. Despite being abandoned, the chapel is
nevertheless a well-known municipal landmark. The closure of the steel industry, a decline in
the population of the city, and the unaffordable maintenance costs are just a few of the causes
of the church’s demise. 
Over time, the church fell into disrepair and became a haunting urban ruin. However, there
have been initiatives to rebuild the area, including securing funding for engineering studies and
stabilization. The continued quest for funding and a long-term strategy to rebuild the historic site goes on despite issues like environmental concern

What kind of religion is Methodist?

Methodists belong to the Protestant tradition within the larger Christian Church. Their beliefs
align with orthodox Christianity and Methodist teaching is often summarized by the four walls.

What do the Methodists believe?

Methodists emphasize the importance of a personal relationship with God that brings about
transformative change in individuals’ lives. They also place great value on serving those in need
within society, viewing faith as a catalyst for compassionate service.

What is the origin of the Methodist Church?

The Methodist Church originated as a revival movement within the Church of England during
the 18th century. After the death of its founder, John Wesley, it emerged as a distinct
denomination. The movement spread rapidly throughout the British Empire, the United States,
and beyond, fueled by dedicated missionary efforts. Today, Methodism boasts approximately
80 million followers worldwide.

Who leads the Methodist Church?

At the Methodist Conference on June 25, 2022, the Reverend Graham Thompson and Anthony
Boateng was formally inducted as President and Vice-President, respectively, of the Methodist

Leave a Comment